Reading Settings
Font Size
16px
Line Spacing
1.6
Reading Width
900px
Font Share
Theme
Text To Speech

160: Chapter 159 Legal Ruling: Agreement Invalid

The Third Courtroom of the Beijing Intermediate Peoples Court.

The gavel fell, making a crisp, wooden striking sound.

Fine dust floated in the air.

The multinational legal delegation dispatched by SM Entertainment sat in the defendant's seats.

The leader of the delegation, South Korea's star attorney Lawyer Kim Jong-ki, had an ashen face. His hands pressed down on the files on the table, the veins on the back of his hands bulging.

In the plaintiff's seats, Zhou Jianjun adjusted his tie and pushed a thirty-page-thick catalog of evidence to the middle of the table.

"Presiding Judge, according to Article 41 of the 'Law of the People's Republic of China on the Choice of Law for Foreign-related Civil Relations', the parties may choose the law applicable to the contract by agreement. However, if no choice is made, the law of the habitual residence of the party whose performance of obligations best reflects the characteristics of the contract shall apply."

Zhou Jianjun's voice was not loud, but his pronunciation was clear. "The plaintiff Su Chen and the other three jointly liable parties have their habitual residences and primary performing arts activities within the borders of China. The place of performance for this contract is China."

Lawyer Kim Jong-ki suddenly stood up and spoke in heavily accented Chinese, "The agreement was signed in Seoul! This is a commercial contract recognized by South Korea! You have no right to interfere!"

"This is Yanjing."

Zhou Jianjun looked up, his gaze cold and sharp. "Abide by the rules here."

Su Chen sat beside Zhou Jianjun, watching Lawyer Kim Jong-ki's flushed face.

He thought to himself: Multinational capital has such a narrow outlook. To think they still want to use outdated rules to oppress people on someone else's turf—they really haven't wrapped their heads around it.

The trial proceeded at an extremely rapid pace.

The court's scrutiny of such multinational agreements, which clearly possessed a malicious restrictive nature, was unprecedentedly strict.

Zhou Jianjun paid no more attention to Lawyer Kim Jong-ki and directly presented three core arguments.

First, the non-compete restriction period is as long as five years, far exceeding China's statutory maximum limit of two years.

Second, SM Entertainment did not provide any reasonable economic compensation during the non-compete period, which constitutes a unilateral, unequal bully clause.

Third, the unlimited joint and several liability in 'Supplementary Annex C' forcibly binds the commercial interests of unrelated third parties, which seriously violates the principle of fairness as well as public order and good customs.

The chain of evidence was a perfect closed loop, leaving absolutely no room for refutation.

"Furthermore."

Zhou Jianjun held up an old copy of a medical diagnosis. "This is the medical evaluation of the lumbar spine injury of Zhang Yixing, one of the plaintiffs, from back then. Knowing full well that he needed to return to China for emergency medical treatment, the defendant's supervisor used this agreement as a condition for his release and forced Su Chen to sign a joint and several guarantee. This is a classic case of personal coercion."

Lawyer Kim Jong-ki sat in his chair, his lips trembling, unable to utter a single word of defense for a long time.

He had brought a thick stack of South Korean legal codes, but he didn't even get the chance to open them in this courtroom.

The presiding judge knocked the gavel.

Court adjourned.

The verdict would be announced at a later date.

Three days later.

During these three days, the Chinese Entertainment Industry was in a state of upheaval.

The schedules of Zhang Yixing, Lu Han, and Huang Zitao were completely halted.

Brands were adopting a wait-and-see attitude, and production crews were waiting.

Public opinion on the internet had not only failed to subside, but had instead grown increasingly intense.

The fans of the three top-tier stars burst forth with astonishing cohesion.

On various social media platforms, the trending topic lists were filled with nothing but expressions of support.

Onlookers in the livestream rooms flooded the comment sections of various gossip accounts every day:

"[It's been three days. When on earth will the verdict be handed down? I'm worried to death.]"

"[If a vampire company like SM can win, I'll eat my keyboard.]"

"[I heard that lawyer Zhou Jianjun has never lost a foreign-related commercial case. It's absolutely in the bag.]"

"[Taozi was still showing off his new sports car in his Super Topic yesterday. His state of mind is truly great.]"

"[God Su must be under immense pressure right now. He must hold on.]"

"[If this kind of indentured contract is protected by law, is there any hope left for the entertainment industry?]"

"[Resolutely boycott South Korean capital, get justice for Su Chen!]"

At the same time.

Seoul, South Korea, SM Entertainment Headquarters.

Park Jung-soo sat in his messy office, which was in complete disarray.

All the telephone lines on his desk had been unplugged.

The legal director pushed the door open and walked in, holding a transnational fax he had just received.

"Representative."

The legal director's voice was dry. "The written judgment from Yanjing has been faxed over."

Park Jung-soo suddenly raised his head and snatched the fax paper.

He quickly scanned the Chinese translation on it, his gaze freezing on the last few lines.

The document slipped from his hand and fell onto the carpet.

Park Jung-soo's legs went weak, and he slumped directly back into his chair.

It's over.

Completely over.

The joint agreement was forcibly invalidated. This not only meant they wouldn't get a single penny of liquidated damages, but it also meant that SM Entertainment's basic market share in China was completely destroyed.

The Chinese partners now had reasonable and legal grounds to terminate their contracts, and a comprehensive withdrawal of capital was already unstoppable.

"Prepare to convene the board of directors."

Park Jung-soo closed his eyes. "Submit my resignation."

Yanjing, Morning Star Dance Studio.

Sunlight shone through the French windows into the meeting room.

The coffee on the coffee table had already gone completely cold.

With a ding, the elevator doors opened.

Zhou Jianjun strode out with large steps, holding an Express Mail Service envelope stamped with the court's red seal.

Lin Yue immediately stood up, her breathing rapid.

Guan Heng and Chen Yu poked their heads out from the training room. The gazes of all fifty people in the studio were focused on that yellow envelope.

Zhou Jianjun walked up to Su Chen and handed over the envelope.

"The civil judgment of first instance from the Beijing Intermediate Peoples Court."

Zhou Jianjun adjusted his gold-rimmed glasses, a rare trace of a smile appearing at the corner of his mouth.

Su Chen took the envelope.

The paper bag was very light, but in his hands, it held a completely different weight.

He tore open the seal and pulled out the neatly bound stack of A4 paper.

He flipped directly to the last page.

In black and white, it was stamped with the bright red seal of the court.

"Upon trial and investigation, this Court has found that the 'Supplementary Annex C' agreement produced by the defendant, SM Entertainment Co., Ltd..."

"The clauses in the agreement regarding the five-year non-compete restriction, the exemption of compensation obligations, and the bundling of third-party joint and several liability are obviously unfair and violate the mandatory provisions of our country's laws as well as the principles of public order and good customs."

"The judgment is as follows:"

"It is confirmed that the 'Supplementary Annex C' non-compete and joint liability agreement signed by the plaintiff and defendant is invalid from the very beginning."

"All defense requests of the defendant, SM Entertainment Co., Ltd., are dismissed. The litigation costs shall be borne by the defendant."

The last few words were written with powerful strokes that seemed to penetrate the paper: Invalid from the very beginning.

Lin Yue leaned over, and upon seeing those words clearly, her eyes instantly turned red. She covered her mouth and stepped aside.

Guan Heng punched the door frame and let out a loud roar, "We won!"

Chen Yu jumped straight up, grabbing Brother Cai's shoulders and shaking him frantically, "Waste paper! That trash contract has turned into waste paper!"

The entire floor erupted into earth-shattering cheers.

Zhou Jianjun looked at Su Chen and extended his right hand. "Mr. Su, congratulations. In a legal sense, South Korea no longer has any provisions that can bind you. Your personal rights and commercial rights have all been taken back."

Su Chen gripped Zhou Jianjun's hand with great force.

"Thank you for your hard work, Lawyer Zhou."

Su Chen's voice was steady.

He thought to himself: It's been five years, and this rusty, broken lock has finally been kicked to pieces.

"You're welcome. When SM's legal team received the written judgment, their expressions must have been quite a sight."

Zhou Jianjun packed up his briefcase. "I have also notified the management agencies of Mr. Zhang and the other two. This afternoon, their stalled commercial contracts will be fully restarted."

Zhou Jianjun turned, stepped into the elevator, and left.

The cheers in the studio were still continuing.

The team members gathered together, some of their tears splashing onto the floor.

The pressure over the past few days had been too great; everyone had been gritting their teeth and enduring it.

Now that this weight had been lifted, everyone felt an unprecedented sense of relief.

Su Chen did not speak.

Holding the written judgment, he turned and walked into his private office.

The main light in the office was not turned on.

The midday sun covered the wooden floor.

He closed the door, completely shutting out the noise from outside.

Su Chen walked to the French windows and looked at the bustling streets of Yanjing outside, where a continuous stream of vehicles reflected the sunlight.

Five years.

Over one thousand eight hundred days.

From the moldy floor of the Seoul basement to struggling forward under a ban after returning to China.

He had always been Dancing with invisible shackles.

He couldn't participate in commercial competitions backed by major capital, couldn't sign formal performing arts contracts, and even the brothers around him had to be constantly on edge.

But now, all of this was over.

The law had given the ultimate ruling, and the five-year shackles shattered with a crash.

The sunlight shone on Su Chen's face, bringing a slight warmth.

He took out his phone and unlocked the screen with his fingerprint.

He opened wechat and found the pinned group chat.

The chat box was completely empty, with the last message still dating back to three days ago.

The one sent by Zhang Yixing: "Go ahead and sue, I'm not afraid."

Su Chen's finger hovered over the virtual keyboard, his gaze lingering on the screen.

Prev Next

🔊 Text To Speech

Listen while reading

Ready